The Interaction of Tradition and Modernity in the Leadership of Papuan Indigenous Peoples: The Case of the Comorian Mimika Tribe, Indonesia

Limi Mokodompit; M. Tahir  Kasnawi; Suparman  Abdullah; Mansyur  Radjab

doi:10.47540/ijqr.v4i1.1418

Authors

Limi Mokodompit Department of Sociology, Hasanuddin University, Indonesia
M. Tahir Kasnawi Department of Sociology, Hasanuddin University, Indonesia
Suparman Abdullah Department of Sociology, Hasanuddin University, Indonesia
Mansyur Radjab Department of Sociology, Hasanuddin University, Indonesia

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.47540/ijqr.v4i1.1418

Keywords:

Indigenous Peoples, Leadership, Modernity, Papua, Tradition

Abstract

This study seeks to ascertain not just the economic repercussions of industrialization on the Mimika tribe in Papua Province, but also how these transformations are altering social and institutional dynamics, notably in terms of traditional leadership. This research was conducted from January 2024 to March 2024 focusing on the Comorian District, especially the Komoro Mimiko Tribe, Papua Province. The data collection techniques used in this study are in-depth interviews with members of the Comoro District, particularly the Comojima tribe, indigenous leaders, industrial workers, and other stakeholders, participatory observation, and holding FGDs with Komoria community groups. The results show that there has been a change in cultural values and traditions stemming from engagement with modern elements. Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs) prioritizing cultural and ecological diversity advocate for the rights of indigenous communities. Conversely, governmental entities adopt a pragmatic stance, viewing modernization as integral to economic advancement. However, they also acknowledge the significance of preserving cultural sustainability and indigenous rights. To this end, they formulate policies facilitating the harmonization of modernities with traditional practices. The interaction between tradition and modernity sees complexity as well as divergence of views among various stakeholders. In general, these results underscore the difficulties and possibilities associated with striking a balance between modernization and indigenous traditions.

References

Aboagye, E. M. (2024). Assessing inclusiveness for indigenous communities in mineral rights allocation in Ghana. Heliyon, 10(8), e29710.

Annandale, M., Meadows, J., & Erskine, P. (2021). Indigenous forest livelihoods and bauxite mining: A case-study from northern Australia. Journal of Environmental Management, 294, 113014.

Auger, M. D. (2016). Cultural continuity as a determinant of Indigenous peoples’ health: A metasynthesis of qualitative research in Canada and the United States. The International Indigenous Policy Journal, 7(4).

Barry, P. (2020). Post-structuralism and deconstruction. Beginning Theory (Fourth Edition), 61–82.

Baruah, B., & Biskupski-Mujanovic, S. (2023). Indigenous women’s employment in natural resource industries in Canada: Patterns, barriers and opportunities. Women’s Studies International Forum, 99, 102784.

Bebbington, A. (2017). Modernization from below: An alternative indigenous development? Development: Critical Essays in Human Geography, 207–225.

Blesia, J. U., Dixon, K., & Lord, B. R. (2023). Indigenous experiences and perspectives on a mining corporation’s community relations and development activities. Resources Policy, 80, 103202.

Buckley, W. (2017). Society as a complex adaptive system. In Systems Research for Behavioral Science (pp. 490–513). Routledge.

Burton, J., Kemp, D., Barnes, R., & Parmenter, J. (2024). Mapping critical minerals projects and their intersection with Indigenous peoples’ land rights in Australia. Energy Research & Social Science, 113, 103556.

Caron, J., Asselin, H., & Beaudoin, J. M. (2020). Indigenous employees’ perceptions of the strategies used by mining employers to promote their recruitment, integration and retention. Resources Policy, 68, 101793.

Carrasco, A. (2015). Jobs and kindness: W.E. Rudolph’s role in the shaping of perceptions of mining company-indigenous community relations in the Atacama Desert, Chile. The Extractive Industries and Society, 2(2), 352–359.

Chi, M. T. H. (1997). Quantifying Qualitative Analyses of Verbal Data: A Practical Guide. The Journal of the Learning Sciences, 6(3), 271–315.

da Silva, C. F. A., de Andrade, M. O., dos Santos, A. M., Falcão, V. A., & Martins, S. F. S. (2023). The drivers of illegal mining on Indigenous Lands in the Brazilian Amazon. The Extractive Industries and Society, 16, 101354.

Dawson, N. M., Coolsaet, B., Sterling, E. J., Loveridge, R., Gross-Camp, N. D., Wongbusarakum, S., Sangha, K. K., Scherl, L. M., Phuong Phan, H., & Zafra-Calvo, N. (2021). The role of Indigenous peoples and local communities in effective and equitable conservation.

Denzin, N. K. (2017). Symbolic Interactionism and Ethnomethodology. Everyday Life: Reconstruction of Social Knowledge, 259–284.

Dlamini, P. N. (2017). The use of information and communication technology tools in managing indigenous knowledge in the province of KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa [Doctoral dissertation]. University of Zululand.

Egunyu, F., & Boakye-Danquah, J. (2024). A systematic review of the socio-economic impacts of mining in Africa: Do research methods influence participation? The Extractive Industries and Society, 17, 101408.

Fath, B. D., Dean, C. A., & Katzmair, H. (2015). Navigating the adaptive cycle: an approach to managing the resilience of social systems. Ecology and Society, 20(2).

Horowitz, L. S., Keeling, A., Lévesque, F., Rodon, T., Schott, S., & Thériault, S. (2018). Indigenous peoples’ relationships to large-scale mining in post/colonial contexts: Toward multidisciplinary comparative perspectives. The Extractive Industries and Society, 5(3), 404–414.

Huang, N., & Ge, L. (2024). Mining and indigenous communities in Southeast Asia: Examining the social impact of mineral development. The Extractive Industries and Society, 17, 101363.

Jackson, C., Vaughan, D. R., & Brown, L. (2018). Discovering lived experiences through descriptive phenomenology. International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management, 30(11), 3309–3325.

Jalata, A., & Dahms, H. F. (2015). Theorizing modern society as an inverted reality: How critical theory and indigenous critiques of globalization must learn from each other. Current Perspectives in Social Theory, 33, 75–133.

Kennedy, C. M., Fariss, B., Oakleaf, J. R., Garnett, S. T., Fernández-Llamazares, Á., Fa, J. E., Baruch-Mordo, S., & Kiesecker, J. (2023). Indigenous Peoples’ lands are threatened by industrial development; conversion risk assessment reveals need to support Indigenous stewardship. One Earth, 6(8), 1032–1049.

Lawrence, R., & Moritz, S. (2019). Mining industry perspectives on indigenous rights: Corporate complacency and political uncertainty. The Extractive Industries and Society, 6(1), 41–49.

Legrand, P. (2017). Paradoxically, derrida: For a comparative legal studies. Derrida and Law, 367–453.

Leyton-Flor, S. A., & Sangha, K. (2024). The socio-ecological impacts of mining on the well-being of Indigenous Australians: A systematic review. The Extractive Industries and Society, 17, 101429.

Lin, G., Xie, X., & Lv, Z. (2016). Taobao practices, everyday life and emerging hybrid rurality in contemporary China. Journal of Rural Studies, 47, 514–523.

Lorca, M., Olivera Andrade, M., Escosteguy, M., Köppel, J., Scoville-Simonds, M., & Hufty, M. (2022). Mining indigenous territories: Consensus, tensions and ambivalences in the Salar de Atacama. The Extractive Industries and Society, 9, 101047.

MacInnes, A., Colchester, M., & Whitmore, A. (2017). Free, prior and informed consent: how to rectify the devastating consequences of harmful mining for indigenous peoples’. Perspectives in Ecology and Conservation, 15(3), 152–160.

Magni, G. (2017). Indigenous knowledge and implications for the sustainable development agenda. European Journal of Education, 52(4), 437–447.

Molina Camacho, F. (2016). Intergenerational dynamics and local development: Mining and the indigenous community in Chiu Chiu, El Loa Province, northern Chile. Geoforum, 75, 115–124.

Myette, E., & Riva, M. (2021). Surveying the complex social-ecological pathways between resource extraction and Indigenous Peoples’ health in Canada: A scoping review with a realist perspective. The Extractive Industries and Society, 8(2), 100901.

Neilson, D. (2015). Class, precarity, and anxiety under neoliberal global capitalism: From denial to resistance. Theory & Psychology, 25(2), 184-201.

Ninomiya, M. E. M., Burns, N., Pollock, N. J., Green, N. T. G., Martin, J., Linton, J., Rand, J. R., Brubacher, L. J., Keeling, A., & Latta, A. (2023). Indigenous communities and the mental health impacts of land dispossession related to industrial resource development: a systematic review. The Lancet Planetary Health, 7(6), e501–e517.

Novoselov, A., Potravny, I., Novoselova, I., Gassiy, V., & Sharkova, A. (2023). Harmonization of interests during Arctic industrial development: The case of mining corporation and indigenous peoples in Russia. Polar Science, 35, 100915.

Nygaard, V. (2016). Do indigenous interests have a say in planning of new mining projects? Experiences from Finnmark, Norway. The Extractive Industries and Society, 3(1), 17–24.

O’Faircheallaigh, C. (2013). Extractive industries and Indigenous peoples: A changing dynamic? Journal of Rural Studies, 30, 20–30.

Parmenter, J., & Drummond, F. (2022). “What did I get myself into?” Indigenous women and mining employment in Australia. The Extractive Industries and Society, 12, 101189.

Savic, K., & Hoicka, C. E. (2023). Indigenous legal forms and governance structures in renewable energy: Assessing the role and perspectives of First Nations economic development corporations. Energy Research & Social Science, 101, 103121.

Siqueira-Gay, J., Soares-Filho, B., Sanchez, L. E., Oviedo, A., & Sonter, L. J. (2020). Proposed Legislation to Mine Brazil’s Indigenous Lands Will Threaten Amazon Forests and Their Valuable Ecosystem Services. One Earth, 3(3), 356–362.

Teske, J. K. (2015). Contradictions in fiction: Structuralism versus Jacques Derrida and deconstruction. Language Under Discussion, 3(1), 1–23.

Torres-Wong, M., & Jimenez-Sandoval, A. (2022). Indigenous resource governance as an alternative to mining: Redefining the boundaries of indigenous participation. The Extractive Industries and Society, 9, 101001.

Upe, A., Salman, D., Agustang, A. (2019). The effects of the exploitation of natural resources towards risk society construction in Southeast Sulawesi Province, Indonesia. Journal of Degraded and Mining Lands Management, 6 (2), 1587-1594.

Yakovleva, N., Gavrilyeva, T. N., Makarov, A. I., & Krasilnikova, N. A. (2023). Free prior informed consent in the extractive industry: Approaches to involving Indigenous peoples in decision-making in Russia. Journal of Environmental Management, 344, 118341.

Yıldız, T. D. (2023). How can shares be increased for indigenous peoples in state rights paid by mining companies? An education incentive through direct contribution to the people. Resources Policy, 85, 103948.

Zhang, X., Li, Y., Lin, J., & Ye, Y. (2021). The Construction of Placeness in Traditional Handicraft Heritage Sites: A Case Study of Suzhou Embroidery. Sustainability 2021, 13(16), 9176.